The results of my survey are in. Thank you to the twelve people who responded. Over 70 people abandoned the survey without answering. You can see the stats below. I’ll break it down under the image.
First of, thank you to the one honest person that said they don’t care; it’s easy to change an apathetic world because no one cares what you do. For a while there the “NOs” were leading. It actually got to me. It started making me think that this experiment is not logical. Then the “YESs” pulled through for me in the clutch.
Here are a few of my favorite “why” comments and my responses. Let’s start with the “NOs.”
NO:
it doesn’t hurt you much, does it?
My first reaction was to agree. I thought, “you know, it’s really not that big of a deal to keep it around. It’s paid off, and I’ve had a car for ten years.” Then I thought of the $5000 credit card debt and the $41,000 student loans. The car doesn’t hurt me much, but the debt does. I’m in the ever continuing quest to slim my expenses.
Being completely car free is not practical. But try and not use it for any short trips (even laundry) and try and keep it to a couple long trips (gf, parents) a month.
When I first got the car back from the shop that was one of my ways to rationalize keeping the it. Using it for longer trips only. Then I started thinking about the fact that the car doesn’t have a fourth gear. My girlfriend lives thirty miles and my parents fifty; it’s probably not the best car for longer distances. In the comments someone gave the suggestion of putting the money saved in gas and insurance towards rentals. If I were to put 100% of it towards rentals then there is no point of me selling the car. But I was thinking of a hybrid version. I could put half or a third towards rentals and use the rest to pay off debt, of course. I have done the math. It’s still cheaper to rent a car twice a month (on the weekends) than own a car.
Use it for backup. Get your insurance reduced to ‘leisure driving’ only for a better rate.
This one has gotten me seriously thinking. I am going to call my insurance company and see what the “leisure driving” rates are. It can’t hurt to find out.
YES:
1) To get the extra cash to pay down credit cards.
2) To save more money. (This blog has a strong financial undertone.) Even though I suggested only spending $30/month in gas, how much would you be spending with Insurance, registration, inspections. . .?
3) You’ve said you’d drive a car if you had one, and it doesn’t sound like you’ve missed a car so far.
4) I don’t know what you demand of a car, but you can probably buy a mostly-reliable older used car for what you would have paid for the transmission.
5) If the car is parked, you’ll start having other problems if you don’t run it every so often.
6) You’re going carless, dammit!!
1 & 2) I really do want to pay my credit cards off. I’ve been slimming down everywhere else. This seems like a good time to try the carless thing.
3) I really have been getting by just fine so far. It’s been three weeks. I only drove the car from when I picked it up to my house.
4) Honestly, this experiment has changed my perception about cars. My coworker made an offhand comment that her friend buys $1000 beaters and drives them into the ground. $1000 a year? That would be four months of a new car payment.
5) You’re right. A car develops problems whether you’re driving it a lot or not.
6) I’m going carless, dammit!!
I sold my car, then recently my scooter…now I just bike everywhere. Someone at work saw me riding the bike and asked: “How do you stay motivated?” my reply: “If you want to get motivated to bike more….sell your car”
That pretty much sums it up!
Conclusion:
I believe you can tell which direction I’m leaning. I agree with the sentiment that I haven’t really missed the car so far. I realize it’s going to get colder for bike riding, but that’s why I got the winter gear. I’m taking a few days to process everything. I have to go through the hoops of trying to sell a car with no fourth gear. Any ideas?
I will leave the survey open as I continue to think about what to do and how to go about it. I have even created a page (link above).
I will keep you in the loop about developments.